- [egg beater whirring]
- Sunny Starscout: [grunting] Ahhh... I've done it!
- [pbbblt!]
- Sunny Starscout: [sighs]
- [pblt]
- Hitch Trailblazer: Heeeey, buddy... How's it goin'?
- Izzy Moonbow: Ooh! Are we dressing like mimes? Fun! I am so ready!
- [French music]
- Izzy Moonbow: Oh! Oh! [laughs]
- Sunny Starscout: Uh, no. I just wanted to make you all your favorite Winter Wishday cookies. But I can't find the recipes anywhere. I mean, I've never even heard of a kiwi-paya crystal unicookie. Or a royal banana nut bite. Or... or...
- Hitch Trailblazer: Grandma Figgy's good-old-fashioned marshmallow citrus crumblies?!
- Sunny Starscout: Exactly!
- Zipp Storm: Hey, don't worry about it, Sun. We haven't eaten those cookies since we were little foals.
- Izzy Moonbow: Yeah, and they're never gonna taste as good as we remember them anyway.
- Sunny Starscout: Oh, really...?
- [opening jingle]
- [whooshing]
- Sunny Starscout: Time for "Operation: Wishday Cookie"! First, I'll get Grandma Figgy's recipe, then I'll get Alphabittle's help in Bridlewood, and then I'll break into the palace at Zephyr Heights to find the top secret royal recipe! Wait. What?
- Grandma Figgy: [humming]
- [door opens]
- Sunny Starscout: Grandma Figgy!
- [thunder]
- Grandma Figgy: Aah! Oof!
- Sunny Starscout: You've got to teach me how to make Hitch's favorite Wishday cookies! Uh, please?
- Grandma Figgy: Hmm... Oh, Sunny! I'd love to teach you! If you think you're ready.
- Sunny Starscout: Uh, w-what?
- ["Sweetest Time of the Year" plays]
- Sunny Starscout: So, uh, do you have the recipe written down somewhere, or...?
- Grandma Figgy: Oh, no, dear. It's all in here.
- Sunny Starscout: Aw, that's sweet. So, how much flour?
- Grandma Figgy: Why, just listen to your heart, and your hooves will follow.
- Sunny Starscout: Oh, boy...
- [doors open]
- Sunny Starscout: Alphabittle, I need your help!
- Alphabittle: Now, stir three times clockwise, throw some salt over your left shoulder, and break an egg with your right hoof. [whispering] That's to chase away the cake ghosts. Aah! I said left shoulder! Do you want cake ghosts?!
- Grandma Figgy: [giggling]
- Sunny Starscout: [whimpering]
- Grandma Figgy: [smooching] Bake with your heart, not with your hooves!
- Alphabittle: [grunting]
- Sunny Starscout: [grunting]
- Alphabittle: Aah! You used the Jinxie spoon!
- [door opens]
- [rolling pin rolling]
- Sunny Starscout: [smooching]
- Queen Haven: [sighs] Such a lovely day to admire our vault of royal secrets.
- Sunny Starscout: Ah!
- Queen Haven: [laughing]
- Grandma Figgy: Hah! [gasps] Now... you're ready.
- Sunny Starscout: Spin four times? Or five times? Add a pinch of, uh... Wait, what was it? Something about a sunbeam?
- [pbbbblt!]
- Sunny Starscout: [coughs, sighs]
- Grandma Figgy: [echoing] Bake with your heart, not with your hooves...!
- Sunny Starscout: My heart, not my hooves.
- [Mane 5]
- 'Cause all I want to do
- Is celebrate with you
- Because I love you
- From my heart to your hooves
- Sunny Starscout: That's... probably fine. [nervous chuckle] Your extra-special Winter Wishday cookies are served.
- Hitch Trailblazer: Come on, Sunny, you didn't have to...
- [bubbling]
- Hitch Trailblazer: ...Oh.
- [fizzling]
- Pipp Petals and Zipp Storm: [gasp]
- [wailing]
- Izzy Moonbow: Oh! Cake ghost!
- Sunny Starscout: Okay, I know they don't look exactly how you remember, but—
- Hitch Trailblazer: No! Uh, they look great!
- Rest of Mane 5: [nervously] Uh-huh.
- Hitch Trailblazer: Can't wait to taste it. Uh... [chomps]
- Pipp Petals and Zipp Storm: [chomp]
- Izzy Moonbow: [chomps]
- Mane 5 sans Sunny: [gulp]
- Young Pipp Petals and Young Zipp Storm: [munching, giggle]
- Young Izzy Moonbow: [munch] Ah!
- Young Hitch Trailblazer: [sighs] Ah! [munch]
- Grandma Figgy: [sighs]
- Mane 5 sans Sunny: [eating rapidly]
- Hitch Trailblazer: [tearfully] Just like Grandma Figgy used to make!
- Pipp Petals: We made a Wishday cookie for you, too!
- Sunny Starscout: Oh! [gasps, chomps] Ugh.
- Hitch Trailblazer: Not sure we got the recipe quite right.
- Mane 5: [laughing]